Rated 4.5 out of 5Â by 6
Rated 5 out of 5Â by cme05 love them
Will wear constantly with boots once it cools down!! No size issues, no quality issues.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by BettinaG Perfect for my legs!
These are one of my two favorite FP warm socks (along with the Netherland Tall Socks, which appear to be gone now). I'm pretty picky about socks, since I want them to stay up over the knee, but not have so much tightness to give me "muffin-top-thighs". These are perfect for my legs. I'm around 5'9", have slightly long legs, medium calves but thicker knees and thighs. These socks meet all my criteria! I'm guessing for someone with very thin legs, they may not stay up too well, but for me they're perfect! I have blue from earlier in fall, and now black - love them both. Please have more colors next year!
Rated 4 out of 5Â by lauren_muhs My favorite FP socks
I was afraid that these wouldn't be as high on me, since I'm 5'10", but just as other reviewers said they reach comfortably above the knee. These socks are so warm, and the color (I ordered grey) is lovely too, I get lots of compliments on them. I would love to order these in additional colors. 4 stars simply because they stretched a bit around the knee
Rated 5 out of 5Â by beena Soft and warm
These socks are great, I love wearing them with boots. The socks hit above the knee for me and don't fall down during the day. They were fine after going through the washing machine, didn't shrink. Would like to get them in another color.
Rated 5 out of 5Â by perirobin Certainly my favorite socks
Oh, I love these! I've got the green from last winter and the oatmeal from this winter. I adore these socks primarily because I find that they are the perfect length, over the kneecap as opposed to other "tall" socks I've worn that are a real pain, hitting the middle of my kneecap and dropping below my knee whilst I walk. After I pull these on, they stay up and keep me warm! Love 'em. I'll probably end up ordering more colors as we get deeper into winter.
Rated 3 out of 5Â by maryhufn Not as tall as the pictures show
I am only 5 ft 1" tall. I wear petite length pants (or get them hemmed). I also fit in size 0 -2 bottoms. In other words, I'm short and little. These socks only function as knee highs for me, not thigh high as the pictures suggest and I though I was purchasing. I can pull them up to the height of the pictures or even higher. And they look great if I stand perfectly still. But they absolutely will not stay up at that height for more than 10 steps. I kept pulling them up every few steps, got sick of it so let them fall and see where they landed. They fell just below my knees and stayed there the rest of the night.
The socks are a nice knit, comfortable to wear, etc... but for them to function as true thigh highs I think they need more elastic or stretch and "hold" ability at the top band.
If these were advertised to be a little shorter and knee high only, I would likely give them 5 stars. The color (oatmeal) is nice, they're comfortable and seem to be well made. But... they're advertised as being "tall socks" and photographed as above the knee socks and they just don't function as such on me unless I stand still. I can't imagine how a taller or fuller physique would fit into these?