"I love this sweater. I'm a small, but I got a large because this thing looks better the bigger it gets (imho). I'm 5'2" and a small, and my usual size hit me shorter but wider than the model... I'm not sure if that makes it fit large or small... probably both. Who cares, size up love this top!"
"I can see how this would be unflattering on some body types..... but i really loved it for me! I'm 5'4ish & slender, and this sweater draped perfectly on my torso. It's a boxy shape, a little shorter hem than I suspected but throw a simple tunic tank underneath or just with denim cutoffs & voila! super cute. The sleeves on mine were perfect...not sure why so many people said the sleeves were 'way too long'. ..or maybe my arms are unusually long. oh well."
"After reading the review on this item, I decided to order it for myself. I normally wear a medium, but chose the small because some said the sizing and shape ran big. I was disappointed when it arrived today. First off the sleeves were so long they went past my finger tips and then some. I agree with another poster... the shape is strange. Unfortunately I will be returning this sweater.."
"I tried this in the blue and the color was great! The fit leaves something to be desired... just oversized. I tried a medium and it was long in the arms and wide in the torso.. The fit was cute but not the most flattering on me... too bad."
"Cayenne to me is a deep reddish orange. This top is coral. Not a bright summer coral, but a fall coral. Nevertheless, it just isn't what you think it will be. They've changed the picture online since I bought it and it does look a bit better/more true to color. As for the fit, they really hide it well in the pics, but you can see below the model's elbow what it does. It's a TRAPEZE top that starts just below the bust! So bizarre and worthless if you have a nice figure. If you have hips you want to hide, this is your top. Otherwise, steer clear because it will just make you look like you are trying to hide something. I'm 5'7" 120 lbs. and thin. This just didn't do anything for me. I liked the sleeves and that's about it."
"buy this if you like babydoll look! super cute but if you are planning to wear leggings with this and you are considerably tall i suggest you buy a medium because it only comes to my waist and im 5 6! but otherwise its great, except for the holes kind of defeat the purpose of a big comfy sweater that keeps you warm..."
"And by cool, I mean cute and cozy. It's a lovely sweater and I got it in the orange because I wanted to wear with the FP Carnival dress in orange. It's also a great sweater to just toss on over a simple tee and jeans. It's perfectly oversized, but I wouldn't recommend sizing up. I got the xs but I also tried on the small. The difference in sleeve length was hilarious. Unless you have freakishly long arms, stick with your usual size."
"totally beautiful sweater! love the pattern and comfy fit. The only reason I rated this as running loose is because of the sleeve length. They look kinda ridiculous on me because they're so long. I'm 5'3" 90 lbs and got the XS. I also tried the small which fit fine, but those sleeves were waaay too long. I think part of the problem is I'm narrow in the shoulders, so the sleeves probably hang even longer on me. still, I bought this one because it's too lovely a sweater to resist."